Normally, I would
have posted this right after the actual ceremony, but work sent me around a
blizzard to Los Angeles, where I didn’t have a break to post this monstrosity
over the last two weeks. But here goes,
anyway.
As is a yearly
tradition; here’s the way that I thought the Academy Awards should have
gone. That is, if I were in charge of
nominating/choosing. One day, when I’m
ruler of the world, I will be.
As usual, I’ve
left out a few categories like documentary and short film, but who really cares
about those anyways? Again, this year,
I’ve included a “My reasoning” section for each category – and don’t worry, not
all of them are fawning over the films I felt were standouts. Again, this year is my “Prediction/Actual
Winner/Should Have Won” section. “Should
Have Won” only applies to films that were nominated and should have won but
were not in my list. Oh, and I worked on
the formatting and revised the “→←”
to indicate which film I would have chosen.
Enjoy! (After the break, of
course…)
BEST PICTURE
→The
Avengers←
The Dark Knight Rises
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
John Carter
Skyfall
Zero Dark Thirty
Silver Linings Playbook
Prediction: Argo
Actual Winner: Argo
Should Have Won: Zero Dark Thirty
My
reasoning: Look, I loved The Dark Knight Rises, and quite
frankly, it along with The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey was the only real competition for the winner. John
Carter was criminally undervalued, and the latest Bond outing will probably
go down as one of the best ever.
Critical darlings like Zero Dark
Thirty and Silver Linings Playbook
usually don’t do much for me, but this year, they were the exception. But when it comes to just a fantastic
movie-going experience, you can’t beat The
Avengers. This was a huge gamble,
and it paid off. I can’t think of one
singular thing I could nit-pick on the film (besides the liberalism of the
actors and director) – which I could find a few things on TDKR and TH:AUJ – so
it gets the coveted title of Scrat’s Favorite Movie of 2012. As for the actual winner, Argo, it was pretty much a foregone conclusion
that this movie would win once ZDT and
Lincoln came under fire from the
usual suspects. So, in turn, Hollywood
honors the movie that honors Hollywood.
Big surprise.
Kathryn Bigelow – Zero Dark Thirty
→Christopher Nolan – The Dark Knight Rises←
→Christopher Nolan – The Dark Knight Rises←
Peter Jackson – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
Andrew Stanton – John Carter
Joss Whedon – The Avengers
Prediction: Steven Spielberg - Lincoln
Actual Winner: Ang Lee – Life of Pi
Should Have Won: David O. Russell – Silver Linings Playbook
My
reasoning: Frankly, I didn’t get
Hollywood’s fascination with Bigelow when she made The Hurt Locker, but I give her props for Zero Dark Thirty. I also
think that Andrew Stanton deserves mad props for having the [gumption] to even
try bringing John Carter to the
screen, much less doing it so well, despite its lack in financial
dividends. Peter Jackson took us back to
Middle-earth with nostalgic flair, and Joss Whedon’s brilliant take on Marvel’s
properties did each character justice.
However, when it comes to sheer directing prowess, it’s pretty hard to
top Christopher Nolan. The man is a
genius behind the camera and was able to transcend genres with his Batman
trilogy. With the actual award, I really
thought Spielberg would pull this one out.
He’s kind of got clout. Clearly
he was punished for something. I haven’t
seen Life of Pi yet, so I can’t
really judge it – but, then again, I haven’t seen Lincoln either, so I really don’t have a horse in this race. All I know is that the Academy was right not
to nominate Ben Affleck, but wrong to snub Bigelow. Oh, and Behn Zeitlin didn’t deserve a
nomination either. Can’t speak for Michael
Haneke.
→Bradley
Cooper – Silver Linings Playbook←
Daniel Craig – Skyfall
Clint Eastwood – Trouble with the Curve
Martin Freeman – The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
Denzel Washington - Flight
Prediction: Daniel Day Lewis - Lincoln
Actual Winner: Daniel Day Lewis - Lincoln
My
reasoning: This was probably the hardest category to throw together, due to the
lack of standout performances this year.
Don’t get me wrong, I love Clint Eastwood, as he’s one of the few alpha
males left in the acting pool, but his performance in Trouble with the Curve has got nothing on his turn in Gran Torino. Once again, Daniel Craig shines as Bond, and
I thought Martin Freeman was the perfect choice to play Bilbo Baggins. I had serious reservations about including
Denzel Washington on the list, as I generally loathed his character in Flight.
He’s a good actor, though, so I’ll give him credit for that. However, it was Cooper who really shined this
year. He wasn’t required to completely
shelve his dead-on comedic side, but his dramatic turn in Silver Linings Playbook was probably the most memorable performance
of the year. The Academy really has a
[love] for Daniel Day-Lewis, so this one wasn’t a surprise. I haven’t seen The Master yet, but it’s got to be better than Joaquin Phoenix’s
last feature. The one actual nominee
that I just couldn’t put on my list was Hugh Jackman. His effort in Les Miserables was noble, but he seemed to overact a bit. Close to my list, but no cigar.
BEST ACTRESS
→Jessica
Chastain – Zero Dark Thirty←
Viola Davis – Won’t Back Down
Anna Kendrick – Pitch Perfect
Jennifer Lawrence – The Hunger Games
Jennifer Lawrence – Silver Linings Playbook
Prediction: Jennifer Lawrence – Silver Linings Playbook
Actual Winner: Jennifer Lawrence – Silver Linings Playbook
My
reasoning: This
category was also quite difficult to put together, despite a real lack of
leading quality this year, on the part of the ladies. If it had been any movie about education that
didn’t have a centrist/pro-school charter message, the Academy would probably
have fawned over Viola Davis in Won’t
Back Down. Instead, they shunned
her, and pretended that movie never happened.
Anna Kendrick has proved time and time again that she is better than the
pathetic movie(s) that made her a household name. She shines in Pitch Perfect, with a supporting cast that really makes that film
this year’s Bridesmaids. This was Jennifer Lawrence’s year. She’s a very talented actress, and gave
credence to The Hunger Games,
elevating it above the awfulness that everyone thought it might be in the wake
of the faux vampire films. She also gave
a powerhouse performance in Silver
Linings Playbook, allowing people to see that she’s got some serious
range. However, after a banner year last
year and her first Oscar nomination, Jessica Chastain mesmerized me in Zero Dark Thirty. Her character was well-written, and she
brought out the beast within, while still being beautiful. She probably won’t didn’t win, because the Academy is likely
offended by the notion that the movie promotes torture, but her performance is
not to be missed. It’s no real surprise
that Lawrence won – after a late surge by Emmanuelle Riva, from Amour, which I haven’t seen. What I do know is that, despite how cute she
was, Quvenzhane Wallis didn’t deserve a nomination. Like Amour,
I haven’t seen The Impossible, so I
can’t judge whether Naomi Watts’ nomination was deserved.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Jason Clarke – Zero Dark Thirty
Robert Downey Jr. – The Avengers
Michael Fassbender – Prometheus
→Tom Hardy – The Dark Knight Rises←
Tom Hiddleston – The Avengers
Actual Winner: Christoph Waltz – Django Unchained
My
reasoning: This was one of the toughest categories to
narrow down. There were so many great
supporting turns by actors this year.
Naturally, I had to give major props to both Robert Downey Jr. and Tom
Hiddleston for their work in The Avengers. Downey almost got a lead actor nod from
me. Michael Fassbender has been pretty
fantastic in almost everything he touches (Shame
aside), so it was nice to see his android character chew up the screen in Prometheus. Jason Clarke was a surprise. Much like Chastain in Zero Dark Thirty, he
kind of un-acted his way through that movie, making his character so very real
in the process. However, I have to give
this one to Tom Hardy. His Bane was able
to hold off Tony and Loki to claim the coveted accolade on my list. He was able to convey so much emotion through
just his eyes to help bring his hulking (pun intended) character to bear in
Christopher Nolan’s masterpiece. Plus, the
man is such a domineering presence every time he’s on screen, that you can’t
really help but marvel (again, pun) at his manifestation. Christoph Waltz’s win was kind of a
surprise. I thought the Academy would be
split over Robert De Niro (SLP),
Phillip Seymour Hoffman (The Master),
and Alan Arkin (Argo), allowing Jones
to ride Day-Lewis’ coattails. Apparently
the Academy’s distain for Lincoln ran
deeper than I thought. Now I want to see
it.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Judi Dench – Skyfall
Anne Hathaway – The Dark Knight Rises
→Anne Hathaway – Les Miserables←
Olivia Wilde – Butter
Rebel Wilson – Pitch Perfect
Prediction: Anne Hathaway – Les Miserables
Actual Winner: Anne Hathaway – Les Miserables
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
The Cabin in the Woods
→Skyfall←
Ted
Wreck-It Ralph
Zero Dark Thirty
Prediction: Django Unchained
Actual Winner: Django Unchained
Should Have Won: Zero Dark Thirty
My
reasoning: I only agreed with the
Academy on nominating ZDT. Mark Boal did a lot better job with this
venture than his tedious, tepid writing on his last project. I haven’t seen Django Unchained, so I don’t want to short-change Quentin Tarantino
here, but I wasn’t drawn to his latest project the way I have been to his last
two. I didn’t think Flight was that original, and the fact that Moonrise Kingdom got a nomination shows just how much of a joke the
Academy has become. The nominees on my
list, however, all had merits. Cabin in the Woods transcended the
horror genre, while Ted was just
another example of Seth Macfarlane’s genius.
Wreck-It Ralph was a nice
distraction, and integrating so many video game characters into the film was
worth noting. However, I have to give it
to the writers of the latest Bond flick.
Skyfall may have covered some
slightly familiar territory, but it stayed true to Ian Fleming’s character and
did so with style. Clearly the Academy
loves Quentin Tarantino’s writing (but not direction), which is why he won
again.
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
The Avengers
The Dark Knight Rises
→The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey←
Les Miserables
Silver Linings Playbook
Prediction: Argo
Actual Winner: Argo
Should Have Won: Silver Linings Playbook
My
reasoning: Of the actual nominees that
I’ve seen, only SLP deserved to be
nominated (and I haven’t read it). Argo was aggravating and Beasts was too artsy and aloof to really
like. I guess I’ll have to judge Lincoln and Life of Pi when I get them on Netflix. I did have to give some credit to the people
who translated Les Miz to the
screen. They kept the themes of the
stage play (and I assume the novel?), without succumbing to typical movie
musical tropes. The movie didn’t work
due to direction, not due to writing.
The two biggest comic book movies were two of the biggest payoffs of the
year, both with their writing and with being just a thrill to see in
theaters. However, when it comes to
literally transferring elements to a screen from a book, none shine more than The Hobbit. If for nothing else, having just read the
book, the “Riddles in the Dark” scene is almost word-for-word the way I
imagined it when I read it. Seeing that
unfold on screen was a joy. This one was
pretty much foregone again, with Argo’s
political trajectory, and the Academy’s aversion to ZDT.
BEST ANIMATED FEATURE
→Brave←
Hotel Transylvania
Ice Age: Continental Drift
Wreck-It Ralph
Prediction: Brave
Actual Winner: Brave
BEST PRODUCTION DESIGN
The Avengers
The Dark Knight Rises
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
→Prometheus←
Zero Dark Thirty
Prediction: Les Miserables
Actual Winner: Lincoln
BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
Act of Valor
The Avengers
→The
Dark Knight Rises←
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
Skyfall
Prediction: Skyfall
Actual Winner: Life of Pi
My
reasoning: This was easy to pick the
nominees, but very difficult to pick a winner.
Before I even saw four of the five films, I figured they’d end up on
this list. Act of Valor was the only surprise.
It was a bold movie, with some very clever cinematography. A few of the scenes in particular were
astounding. The other four films were
works of art, as expected. The Avengers was a joy to see in three
dimensions, as was The Hobbit, but it
really came down to Skyfall vs. The Dark Knight. Each had their merits, and each deserved to
win. Having each film in theaters on
multiple occasions, it was difficult to choose.
Skyfall had some brilliant set
pieces that showcased the cinematography, but it lacked the epic scope that was
The Dark Knight Rises. Christopher Nolan’s Batman swan-song provided
some massive camera work, and the IMAX format helped showcase his vision. The work was incredibly effective, and thus,
it gets the accolade. I kind of figured Skyfall had this one, but Life of Pi’s win wasn’t terribly
surprising. There’s kind of a theme with
the Academy every year. This year was
the Argo-Life of Pi show. Like so
many categories, I haven’t yet caught Life
of Pi, Anna Karenina, Django Unchained, or Lincoln yet, so this was kind of a
category I can’t show a whole lot of spite toward when it comes to the actual
ceremony.
BEST COSTUME DESIGN
→The Dark Knight
Rises←
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
John Carter
Les Miserables
Prometheus
Prediction: Les Miserables
Actual Winner: Anna Karenina
My
reasoning: This one was an unlikely toss-up.
With Les Miserables holding
the period piece spot for the year, the nominees left were of the
sci-fi/fantasy realm. With The Hobbit, it was lovely to see the
amount of detail from the wardrobe department, but it was almost a
been-there-done-that kind of feeling.
With John Carter, it was much
the same. What it came down to was a
toss-up between The Dark Knight Rises
and Prometheus. Unlikely, as I said. With Prometheus,
the level of detail that went into the space suits was impeccable, as was the
other designs that gave each character personality – particularly that of
Charlize Theron’s. However, I have to
give this one to The Dark Knight Rises. From regal to tactical, the costumes in this
film ran the gauntlet of range. Batman’s
suit alone is a marvel, but add Bane and Catwoman in there, and you’ve really
got a department who knows what they’re doing.
Even though I haven’t seen Anna
Karenina, it’s a period piece, so it’s not a huge shocker that it won. Same would have been said for Lincoln, but the Academy didn’t like
it. I just figured that Les Miserables would be the Oscar
darling of the night, next to Argo and
Life of Pi. As for the other two actual
nominees, I’d like to say I hadn’t seen them, but unfortunately I have. I guess the costumes were probably one of the
better aspects of each movie.
BEST EDITING
→The Avengers←
The Dark Knight Rises
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
John Carter
Skyfall
Prediction: Argo
Actual Winner: Argo
Should Have Won: Zero Dark Thirty
My
reasoning: This was a tough category to
choose the winner. The nominees were fairly easy to pick, but the winner was
tough. It really came down to a
three-way tie between The Avengers, The Dark Knight Rises, and Skyfall.
Don’t misunderstand me. The Hobbit and John Carter were well edited, but there were a few parts that
probably could have been trimmed or reworked.
However, I’m going to have to give this one to The Avengers. While The Dark Knight Rises and Skyfall were impeccable, the monumental
task of allowing each of the heroes represented in Marvel’s assembly film a
chance to shine was the determining factor here. And the love affair with Argo continues. I don’t get
it. Edit this thing down to a 30 minute
documentary about Ben Affleck’s Bieber hair and it still would have been too
long. Can’t judge Life of Pi or Lincoln,
but SLP or ZDT would have been better choices.
BEST MAKEUP
The Avengers
→The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey←
John Carter
Les Miserables
Prometheus
Prediction: Les Miserables
Actual Winner: Les Miserables
My
reasoning: I actually agreed with the Academy on the films that I had
seen. However, I couldn’t whittle this
category down to three. The Avengers and Prometheus proved that makeup helps make sci-fi. John
Carter showed us make-up from Mars, circa 1865., and Les Miserables was the period piece of the year when it came to the
category. However, when you think about
the hours the cast from The Hobbit spent
in the make-up chairs, as well as the detail the department went to to achieve
the look for the new high-frame rate; that movie walks away with this
prize. I’m kind of surprised that Argo wasn’t nominated due to the Bieber
hair on display. Otherwise – other than Hitchcock, which I haven’t seen but understand
why it got nominated – not a terribly surprising category.
BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
Brave – Patrick Doyle
→The Dark Knight Rises – Hans Zimmer←
The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey – Howard Shore
John Carter – Michael Giacchino
Skyfall – Thomas Newman
Prediction: Life of Pi – Mychael Danna
Actual Winner: Life of Pi – Mychael Danna
My
reasoning: While I have only seen two of
the five actual nominees, only one ends up on the list. The music for Skyfall, like the other two revamped Bond films, is quite
suiting. Paired with Adele’s song, they
make for a winning combination. However,
you can’t discount the music from both John
Carter nor Brave. Both scores were quite suiting to their
respective films, and helped elevate the material, rather than bury it. Still, these three movies didn’t give you the
nostalgic factor that Howard Shore brought along with him for The Hobbit. What a great way to re-visit the music of the
majestic trilogy, while create something wholly new in the process. Add all these films together, however, and
you might be able to match the grandeur of maestro Hans Zimmer’s bombastic
score from The Dark Knight Rises. The man is sheer genius, and his latest score
speaks for itself. This was an
interesting category for the actual award…or not. It was either going to be Danna for Life of Pi or Alexandre Desplat for Argo.
No surprise. I’ll judge John
Williams and Dario Marianelli when I see Lincoln
and Anna Karenina, but I pretty much
guarantee they’re better than the aforementioned duo.
BEST ORIGINAL SONG
“For You” by Keith Urban – from Act of Valor
“Live to Rise” by Soundgarden – from The Avengers
“Made of Stone (Renholder Remix)” by
Evanescence – from Underworld Awakening
“Safe and Sound” by Taylor Swift and The Civil
Wars – from The Hunger Games
→“Skyfall” by
Adele – from Skyfall←
Prediction: “Skyfall”
Actual Winner: “Skyfall”
My
reasoning: This year was a little easier
to find songs to pick from films than last year, and this year’s winner was so
clear. Adele is just brilliant. Her work for the latest Bond film is just
icing on the cake of what has become of her career. She’s not going away any time soon – and
that’s just fine with me. I was very
glad to see country artists embrace Act
of Valor, and Keith Urban’s song was a great fit for the film. Initially, I didn’t care much for
Soundgarden’s return for The Avengers
soundtrack, but the song grew on me. I
love Evanescence, so hearing their song at the end of the latest Underworld
film was great. The only real threat to
Adele this year was from someone I generally loathe. I pretty much detest everything Taylor Swift
does, but her collaboration with The Civil Wars (and T. Bone Burnett) for The Hunger Games soundtrack was
noteworthy, and shocking when you realize who you’re listening to. It’s no surprise that Adele won, but
apparently I need to see Ted again,
so I can listen to “Everyone Needs a Best Friend”. “Suddenly” from Les Miserables didn’t do much for me (much the way the second half
of the film didn’t), and I won’t be seeing Chasing
Ice, but the fact that Scarlett Johansson sang an Oscar-nominated song is interesting. Oh, and I’ll judge the song from Life of Pi in time.
BEST SOUND EDITING
Act of Valor
→The Avengers←
The Dark Knight Rises
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
John Carter
Prediction: Skyfall
Actual Winner: (tie) Skyfall and Zero Dark Thirty
My
reasoning: I did a little research, and
it appears that this category is designed to recognize sound effects. I don’t think there was a bigger movie this
year than The Avengers, and the sound
effects for it were top-notch. Whether
it was Thor’s thunderbolts or the Hulk’s roar, they were right on. The other nominees had riveting sound effects
to boot, but none had the massive scale of an alien race invading Manhattan and
superheroes fighting back. Apparently a
category can tie for a winner? Skyfall shares with Zero Dark Thirty? And Argo didn’t win? This was a weird category for the actual
award. I’ll judge Life of Pi and Django
Unchained in due time.
BEST SOUND MIXING
The Avengers
→The Dark Knight
Rises←
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey
John Carter
Skyfall
Prediction: Skyfall
Actual Winner: Les Miserables
My
reasoning: From what I understand, this category is how well each of the
elements of sound mesh together.
Dialogue, music, sound effects, etc.
The reason I gave it to The Dark
Knight Rises over the other films
is due to how well Hans Zimmer’s bombastic score was integrated into the
film. The other sound effects were right
on, but the music meshed perfectly with them.
The other nominees were just as admirable as far as the sounds went, but
lacked that invigorating umph that Zimmer provided. It’s not a complete shocker that Les Miserables won. A musical usually takes this award. I just figured Skyfall had a better chance.
As for Lincoln and Life of Pi, you know the drill. It’s just surprising that the Academy didn’t
just give Argo this one too.
BEST VISUAL EFFECTS
The Avengers
→The Hobbit: An
Unexpected Journey←
John Carter
Prometheus
Prediction: Life of Pi
Actual Winner: Life of Pi
Wrap up:
Looking
back, I’m actually kind of glad I missed the ceremony. Sure, I would have liked to have seen Seth
Macfarlane at work. The man is a comic
genius – despite his leftist views.
Unfortunately, like so many other Oscar shows, this one must have been
dripping with Hollywood’s self-congratulatory smugness. Of the nominees for Best Picture that I had
actually seen, Argo was my least
favorite. Big shocker that it won. So many other films were far more deserving
of recognition. And make no mistake, the
complete shut-out of The Dark Knight
Rises will not be forgotten. I’m
done. On to something else.
Last
year, I was looking forward to a slew of movies. Some turned out great (Skyfall, Ted, Act of Valor, The Avengers, The Dark Knight
Rises, The Hobbit: An Unexpected
Journey), some good (John Carter,
Dredd, Total Recall, Brave, Prometheus), some mediocre (The
Amazing Spiderman, Battleship, Les Miserables, Sparkle, The Bourne Legacy,
Ice Age: Continental Drift, Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, Men in Black III), some poor (Rock of Ages, Resident Evil: Retribution,
Wrath of the Titans, Mirror Mirror, Lockout,
Dark Shadows), and some were just plain flops (Snow White and the Huntsman).
Some I didn’t get around to seeing (Django
Unchained, Red Dawn), and some didn’t even come out (G.I. Joe: Retaliation, Gravity,
World War Z, The Great Gatsby). Plus, I
didn’t even try to see some of the Oscar movies in theaters that I might have (Lincoln, Life of Pi, The Master, The Impossible, The Sessions, Anna Karenina,
Amour, Hitchcock) after last year’s disappointing research.
This
year, I’ve got another slew of movies to look forward to. Hopefully I’ll actually get to see GIJ:R, Gravity, WWZ, and Gatsby this year, as well as other
interesting prospects like Oz: The Great
and Powerful, Olympus Has Fallen,
The Croods, Evil Dead, 42, Oblivion, After Earth, The Internship,
The Lone Ranger, R.I.P.D., Percy Jackson: Sea
of Monsters, Carrie, Ender’s Game, The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, and Jack Ryan As well as
possibilities like Pain and Gain, To the Wonder, Scary Movie 5, The Hangover:
Part III, This is the End, The Heat, White House Down, Elysium,
Riddick, I, Frankenstein, Machete
Kills, Rush, The World’s End, and (begrudged, as I know it will be terrible) Fast & Furious 6. And
of course, the obvious ones like Jurassic
Park 3D, Iron Man 3, Star Trek Into Darkness, Man of Steel, Kick-Ass 2, Despicable Me 2,
Pacific Rim, The Wolverine, 300: Rise of
an Empire, Red 2, Sin City: A Dame to Kill For, Thor: The Dark World, and The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug. Yeah, I’m going to go broke.
(And yes, I realize that some of this is a formatting fail, but I don't care.)
(And yes, I realize that some of this is a formatting fail, but I don't care.)
No comments:
Post a Comment